Op. 9, No. 1, Measure 73

I learned Chopin's B-flat minor Nocturne using the Schirmer edition, favorite edition of broke college students everywhere. When Deborah and I were going to work on the F-minor Nocturne (which I barely started before I had to quit), she had me get the Alfred edition. So when I decided to do a chord analysis of the whole piece (B-flat minor, I mean), I pulled out the Alfred since it wasn't covered with fingering, jotted notes, and other scribbles.

When I sat down to get the piece from memory a couple of weeks ago, I went back to Schirmer. Here's measure 73, which I'm still working on getting "just right."

So the Schirmer and the Alfred are both lying around. When I sat down to work on measure 73 today, I grabbed the version that was closest at hand: the Alfred. Here's measure 73 of the Alfred:

I have the measure 73 polyrhythms down for the most part, but I'm not confident about them. When they come together properly, it feels like more a stroke of luck than something I've consciously executed. So for today's practice, I wanted to see if I could make that "stroke of luck" be more consistent. So I looked at my Alfred edition, to remind myself of how many RH notes I'd practiced for each LH note.

And ... something was different. The Alfred edition is not like the Schirmer edition. And neither of them are the official Urtext edition, at least as far as I know.

In Schirmer, the first three triplets are 3-against-2 with the LH. After that, we have the rather-hard-to-digest 20-against-6, starting with the Bb in the right hand and a Bb2 (the Bb an octave below Middle C) in the left:

As noted above, that Bb2 is the first note of the second set in the LH, and the seventh note in the measure.

In Alfred, we have "3 against 1" for the initial three-note sets, and then the 20-note run starts on the fourth note of the measure, the Bb3:

Aaarrrggghhh.

So I did what I always do when I'm not sure about something in Chopin: Asked, "What would Artur do?"

Artur Rubinstein, 1962

So I listened. And ... it's kind of hard to tell.

I prefer the version I learned originally. I don't know if it matters that I play this many notes against that one note, or if I'm strict about anything as long as it's beautiful and comes together in the end. I'm just going to go with my instinct here. I'll continue working on having the progression of notes in both the RH and LH feel as natural as possible. This will allow me to think less about this note or that note, this beat or that beat, and just enjoy the flow of the music under my fingers.

Comments

Rethinking Bare Necessities

Today's breakthrough moment (there are actually two of them) focuses on "Bare Necessities." As you'll remember, I discovered Jonny May's arrangement back in early March and immediately decided to learn it. I printed out the music, started the course, and proceeded to learn the stride section, posting a few videos of my progress. Ha. I bet those videos make it look like I was making progress. I guess I was ... but not really. And I realized something this weekend that I hadn't before: Because I was thinking of "Bare Necessities" as a "fun" piece, I wasn't practicing it seriously or diligently. I wasn't treating it as something I wanted to master. This mindset might work with an easier piece, but this arrangement isn't easy. The result: despite a little progress at the outset, I wasn't moving forward. I was stalled. Breakthrough #1 The first breakthrough was realizing that if I truly want to learn this piece and play it well,...

March Goals Recap/Looking Ahead to April

It's April 1, and time to revisit the goals I set for last month. I practiced a total of 50.45 hours in March, averaging 1.62 hours (or just over an hour and a half) per day. Realistically, I practice about 45 minutes to an hour a day on weekdays, and I usually get at least one longer practice (or multiple shorter practices) in on one or both days of the weekend to bring the average up. CLASSICAL GOALS Chopin, F Minor Nocturne March Goal: Have entire piece by memory and performance-ready. I have about 90% of the piece by memory, but I still have some work to do before it's performance-ready. The only two sections that I don't quite have are "The Agitation" and the "stretto" section with the seventh chords. I'll work on both this week and will have them both memorized before the weekend. April Goal: Finish memorizing, and polish, polish, polish! My focus now is really on phrasing and dynamics. I have the notes down, even in the difficult passages. Fro...

Maple Leaf Rag Breakthrough

Oh, Maple Leaf. Where to begin? At the Beginning I think I’ve mentioned this before, but I learned the A and B sections of Maple Leaf Rag back in the 1990s. I can’t tell you if it was early, mid- or late 90s, but it was during those 10 years after I’d graduated college, when I was playing a good bit of piano but not taking regular lessons from anyone. I don’t remember teaching it to myself at all. I just know that, at some point, the first half of Maple Leaf Rag was part of my two- or three-song repertoire of pieces I’d be able to play by memory over the next 25 years. It was always sloppy and I knew it, but people loved it, and so I played it if there was ever a piano around. Back in January, I decided to properly re-learn those two sections, and to finally learn the C and D sections of this wonderful piece. I worked on these over the next month or two, learning (and-relearning) the notes pretty quickly ... but it took time to memorize, and also to get everything to tempo surpassing a...

Picking Up the Pieces

Search This Blog